Internosis - knowledge management,ecommerce and project consulting
*Home>>>Application Development

Is a linux from scratch build open source? Can my company really stop people having the source for free?


The company I work for has built a distribution using the "linux from scratch" route and built it from source. They intend to sell it on for loads of money but refuse to let even us "in-house" linux users from getting the source or modifying it to help us deploy it easier. Is this legal? and if so does that not go against the whole "open source" ethos?
The single application they run on the new OS is a in-house development ported from DOS, but how do they stand on licensing that too?

Just a bit confused,
G.

From what I understand, 100% open source is just that - you have the right to compile it and then sell it for money. Unethical yes, but the FSF basically wants GNU/Linux to be free to do as you please. It's what Xandros, Linspire, Vida Linux and a couple of other companies are doing. I don't know if you can make it closed source, though...

I guess, at the same token, the customers are free to do their research, find the software and compile it themselves.

I can't see any issues from porting a program from one OS to another, created in house. The power is held by the creator in this instance, I don't think anyone can dictate how it can be licensed.

It depends on the specific license. Generally, more open-source licenses require that you provide the source code to anything you derive from the original software. They are allowed to sell it, but they cannot make the source code exclusive.

As I understand it the open source license clearly states that the "cost" of using open source as a basis for your innovations is that you make the source of your improvements open as well.

Of course, as with most legal issues the devil is in the details. However, on the surface it appears as though the company is violating the intent, and perhaps even the letter, of open source licensing.

Tags
  E-Commerce   Supply Chain   Data Mining   ERP   CRM   Application Development   Software Consulting   Software Development   Information Technology   Technology Consulting   Project Training
Related information
  • Artificial limbs?

    not only limbs u can also go for other parts of body.particularlly for limbs biotec.,genetic eng,. i dout which sub u want .biology?, physics ? at shhool level studying both is good &in uni. t...

  • Failing to connect to remote SQL Server 2000 from ASP.NET 2.0?

    So... I am not clear from your information - have you or have you not enabled remote connections using the Surface Area Configuration manager for your SQL 2005 instance?

    ...
  • Can you give me a hand?

    looks great to me! have a nice day!

    ...
  • How can IT developer find job in the UK if he has no practice in spoken English, but good writting skills?

    You haven't said what your first language is. Without decent spoken English skills colleagues would imagine they would have problems discussing software build and testing plans with you. There...

  • How is applications of differentiation related to calculus of variation?

    In Calculus of Varations deals with minimization problems the most elementary of which is the Brachistochrone. This is the problem of the shape of a wire which provides the fastest path between tw...

  • Why are people slow to take torture of women seriously?

    Most people are too disconnected from the incidents. Although they hear about it on the news and feel some empathy for the women and men involved, the next day it's back to work/school and the...

  • Best folder structure?

    Well, the best folder structure is to allow for the different areas (GL, AP, AR...) under their respective folders. You should also allow for the ability to introduce newer version of each program...

  • Where can I get funding to start a business?

    Princess trust is a good idea and the age limit is up to 30. They can give you a low interest loan of 拢1000 - 拢5000 providing you have a detailed business plan, cash flow forecast and sales foreca...

  •  

    Categories--Copyright/IP Policy--Contact Webmaster